The Perfect Bathtub for Your Bathroom Renovation-Freestanding Vs Insert Bathtub
Not sure which bathtub to choose? I get it—there are so many options these days, and the price range can be all over the place. But don’t stress! I’ve broken it down into a few popular types to help you out. Every bathtub has its pros and cons, so it really comes down to what suits your space and plumbing setup. Once you know what you’re working with, it’s actually pretty easy to narrow it down. Let’s take a look at some of the top options to make your decision easier!
Table of Contents
Did you know that working with an interior designer comes with special supplier discounts? Here’s a treat for you! Get an exclusive discount on bathware at The Blue Space using this link.
1. Freestanding Bathtub
Design Impact: Freestanding bathtub are a bold statement piece that can instantly make your bathroom feel luxurious. Their sculptural quality means they work well in spacious bathrooms, where the tub can be positioned centrally or along a feature wall. These tubs come in various styles, from traditional clawfoot designs to sleek, modern forms, making them incredibly versatile for different aesthetics. Freestanding baths can create a spa-like experience, and the “wow” factor they bring can significantly elevate the look of your bathroom.
Renovation Considerations:
- Space: Freestanding bathtubs require ample room, not just for the tub itself but for access around it. They work best in larger bathrooms, where they can be the centerpiece, but a smaller freestanding tub can also fit in more compact spaces.
- Plumbing: These tubs typically require floor-mounted faucets or wall-mounted taps. Plumbing for a freestanding tub can be more complex and costly, as it often requires additional work for water lines and drainage, especially in older homes.
Pros:
- Eye-catching and luxurious, with high visual impact.
- Versatile placement, offering flexibility in layout.
- Available in a wide variety of styles and materials like acrylic, cast iron, and stone.
Cons:
- Requires more space, limiting use in smaller bathrooms.
- Can be expensive, especially with added plumbing work.
- Can be difficult to clean around, especially if the tub is positioned too close to walls.
2. Insert Bathtub
Design Impact: Insert bathtubs, also known as built-in or inset baths, are installed within a built-up frame or recess, with only the top edge visible. These tubs are ideal for creating a sleek, seamless look in your bathroom, as the surrounding area can be tiled or finished to match your overall design. Insert baths are popular in bathrooms where a streamlined, integrated appearance is desired, and they work particularly well in contemporary and minimalist designs.
Renovation Considerations:
- Custom Surrounds: Insert bathtubs require a custom-built platform or surround, which can add to renovation costs but offers significant design flexibility. The surround can be finished in a range of materials, from ceramic tiles to wood, allowing you to match the tub to your overall bathroom design.
- Space Efficiency: These baths are great for small bathrooms, as they can be fitted snugly into a corner or against a wall, making the most of the available space. The surround also offers opportunities for built-in storage, like shelves or ledges, which can enhance the functionality of the space.
Pros:
- Seamless, integrated look.
- Surround can be customized with a variety of materials, from tiles to natural stone.
- Space-efficient for smaller bathrooms.
- Easy to maintain and clean since the edges are flush with the wall or platform.
Cons:
- Requires a custom-built surround, adding to renovation time and cost.
- Typically not as deep as freestanding tubs, making them less ideal for soaking.
3. Corner Bathtub
Design Impact: Corner bathtubs are perfect for awkward or tight bathroom layouts, making efficient use of corner spaces. Their triangular shape offers a larger bathing area compared to traditional tubs, making them both a functional and aesthetic choice. Corner baths can also serve as a design statement in modern or contemporary bathrooms, where they soften the room’s angular geometry. They’re great for creating a cozy, inviting nook within the bathroom.
Renovation Considerations:
- Space Utilization: By fitting into a corner, these bathtub maximize floor space and free up room for other fixtures like vanities or storage. They work well in medium to large bathrooms but may feel a bit overwhelming in smaller spaces.
- Custom Fit: Many corner tubs require custom surrounds or tiling to create a cohesive look, which can add to renovation costs. They also tend to be bulkier, so careful planning is needed to ensure they don’t dominate the room.
Pros:
- Makes the best use of corner spaces, especially in awkwardly shaped rooms.
- The larger bathing area provides a more luxurious experience.
- Creates a cozy and relaxing bathing nook.
Cons:
- Bulky shape can dominate smaller bathrooms if not properly planned.
- May require more custom work for installation and surrounds, adding to costs.
4. Back-to-Wall Bathtub
Design Impact: Back-to-wall bathtubs offer the elegance of a freestanding bath with the practicality of being installed against a wall. This design works well for homeowners who want the look of a freestanding tub but need to save on space. With their sleek and contemporary design, back-to-wall baths provide a minimalist, streamlined aesthetic that blends well in both modern and traditional bathrooms.
Renovation Considerations:
- Space Efficiency: Back-to-wall tubs save valuable floor space while still providing the visual appeal of a freestanding tub. They are perfect for medium-sized bathrooms where a completely freestanding tub might not be feasible.
- Plumbing: These baths are easier to install than fully freestanding models, as plumbing can be concealed within the wall. This reduces the complexity of the installation and can help keep costs down.
Pros:
- Combines the visual appeal of freestanding tubs with the space-saving benefits of wall-mounted installations.
- Easier and cheaper to install compared to freestanding models.
- Suitable for both large and small bathroom designs.
Cons:
- Requires placement against a wall, which limits flexibility in room layout.
- Doesn’t have the same dramatic impact as a fully freestanding tub.
A Common Misconception:
Insert Tubs Look Cheap,
Freestanding Tubs Are Luxurious??
When I first got into design, I was all about freestanding tubs. I had this idea that they were the ultimate luxury, and anything else—like insert tubs—just didn’t measure up. But as I got deeper into designing bathrooms and seeing how different tubs fit into various spaces, I realized that’s not always the case. It’s actually a pretty common misconception that freestanding tubs are automatically more luxurious and insert tubs are somehow “cheap” or less stylish. In reality, both types can look stunning if you approach the design the right way.
Insert bathtub, for example, don’t have to be boring. Just because you can’t see much of the tub itself doesn’t mean it can’t be a design feature. In fact, you can really play around with the surroundings and create something unique that fits perfectly into your bathroom’s vibe. Imagine an insert tub with a sleek, concrete surround, or maybe some beautiful wood finishes, or even small, mosaic tiles that give it a textured, custom look. You can also add built-in platforms for storage or seating, making the whole space feel more integrated and functional. The best part? You have way more flexibility to get creative with what’s around the tub.
Freestanding tubs, while definitely eye-catching, can sometimes take up a lot of space. Sure, they work well in larger bathrooms, but they’re not always practical in smaller ones. Plus, just because a tub is freestanding doesn’t automatically make it feel more luxurious—it really depends on the overall design of the space. If you have a beautifully tiled insert tub with great finishes, it can easily rival or even surpass the look of a freestanding one.
So, if you’re leaning towards an insert tub, don’t feel like you’re settling for something less. It’s all about how you style it, and in some cases, insert tubs can be the more practical (and even stylish!) option.
Keep an open mind, look for inspiration, and get creative!
To wrap it all up, when you’re picking out a bathtub for your bathroom reno, it’s all about finding the right balance between looks and practicality. Freestanding tubs are a big hit if you want that “wow” factor—they’re super stylish and give off a luxurious vibe, but they do need a good amount of space to really shine.
If space is a bit tight, insert and back-to-wall tubs are great because they offer way more flexibility. You can get creative with the design around them, and they fit nicely into smaller spaces without sacrificing style. Then there are corner tubs, which are like a secret weapon for tricky or awkward layouts—they maximize every inch and still manage to give you a super cozy, spa-like feel.
At the end of the day, the right tub for you comes down to a few things: how much space you’ve got to work with, your personal style, and of course, your budget. Every tub has its own perks, so it’s all about figuring out what fits your vision and the space you’ve got. Whether you’re going for something sleek and modern or more traditional and cozy, there’s a tub out there that’s perfect for you!
Ready to Create Your Dream Space?
Your home should feel beautiful and functional — and that’s where I come in.
Start with a 90-minute consultation ($550). You’ll get:
- A deep dive into your ideas and challenges
- Expert, personalised advice
- A written report with clear next steps
Contact me today to begin your design journey.
Email: Jacqueline@thegladedesign.com
